Stan Grant is one of Australia’s best-known journalists and public commentators. I always look forward to his fortnightly column in the Saturday Paper. A proud Wiradjuri man, Grant has spent decades reporting from around the world — covering war, politics, race, and national identity. In recent years, his writing has become a reflective moral and spiritual voice in Australian public life. His focus has turned inward, exploring silence, grief, meaning, and the limits of modern public discourse.
When Words Fail Us is a small but thoughtful meditation on what happens when language itself begins to feel exhausted. In an age of endless commentary, outrage, slogans, and online fury, he wonders whether we have lost the capacity truly to listen. Early in the book he confesses simply: “I am out of words.” That line sets the tone for everything that follows.
This book mourns the loss of, and the indispensable role of silence, contemplation, and attentiveness. Grant argues that modern culture mistakes noise for wisdom. We react instantly but reflect rarely. We speak constantly but often fail to hear one another. Drawing on philosophy, poetry, spirituality, Indigenous wisdom, and music, he searches for a deeper and more humane way of being in the world.
Some of the most moving parts of the book come when Grant reflects on the necessity of silence not as emptiness. He writes: “Silence is not the absence of meaning; it is where meaning begins.” That insight runs through the whole work. We have lost our humanity because we have lost our connection with Mystery – whether that is God, Land, Vulnerability. With blind faith in reason, science, technology, we are left believing we are the creators of meaning, and infallible with whatever we think is the truth. Reality is our creation. Whatever we decide is morally OK.
Grant’s writing is more like a personal journal of exhaustion and hope. That is precisely its strength. Grant gives voice to a feeling many people experience today: fatigue with anger, division, and the relentless demand to have an opinion about everything.
There is also a deeply spiritual quality beneath the writing. Even when not explicitly religious, the book echoes the wisdom traditions that understand silence, attention, and humility as pathways to truth. Therapist, theology, spirituality, morality, and ethics combine.
Grant’s thoughts spring from the writings of Simone Weil, a French Jewish philosopher who died during W.W.2 . She could not convert and abandon her Jewish sisters and brothers in concentration camps. Exiled in Britain, she ate only what the Jewish prisoners were receiving. Weil laboured in a factory and died of TB and exhaustion. Stop talking and listen; listen to the lessons only silence can tell you. But listen in awareness of where you are listening. It’s not power, or control or being first, or being best. The secret lies in being vulnerable.
If all that sounds too religious, spiritual, Grant doesn’t ask us to abandon the world. In the full awareness of the present horrors, violence, bigotry and killings, Grant invites us to reclaim the space to be truly human.
If you have a story to share, email us here
For our previous sharings: